All states › Antique Malls › New York › Ithaca

Antique Malls in Ithaca, NY

3 of the 10 antique stores we list in Ithaca have multiple dealers selling under one roof. A Google listing just says "antique store," whether it's one owner's shop or a warehouse split into 200 rented booths — and that difference changes how you shop entirely. Every mall tagged here was confirmed through the business's own site or its posted dealer directory, not guessed from the name.

Found In Ithaca Multi-dealer mallFurnitureJewelry & coins

227 Cherry St, Ithaca, NY 14850-5024

16073195078 Website Directions

Ithaca Antique Center Multi-dealer mall

1607 Trumansburg Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850-9213

+16072723611 Directions

Mimi's Attic Multi-dealer mallFurnitureOpen Sunday

Ithaca, NY 14850

🕒 Sat 10am-6pm, Sun 12pm-6pm

(607) 882-9038 Website Directions

Budget at least an hour, not fifteen minutes. A true antique mall runs dozens to hundreds of independent booths, so pricing and haggle room vary dealer to dealer — a booth with a business card and "make offer" tag is often negotiable, while a locked case marked by the mall's front desk usually isn't. Ask at checkout which booth an item came from if you want to talk price directly with the dealer next time.

Also in Ithaca

More in Ithaca and New York

Antique Malls near Ithaca

Good to know

What's the difference between an antique mall and an antique store?
An antique store is typically one owner curating and pricing everything themselves. An antique mall (also called a multi-dealer mall) rents out booth or case space to dozens or hundreds of independent dealers who each set their own prices, and the mall just staffs a shared front register — think Antique Archaeology-style co-ops rather than a single shopkeeper.

Can you negotiate prices at an antique mall?
Often yes, but it depends on the individual dealer, not the mall. Many booths post a phone number or business card inviting offers, and some malls run a "make an offer" slip system where staff call the dealer for you; locked glass cases and consignment items are less flexible than open shelf booths.