All states › Antique Consignment Shops › New York › Staten Island

Antique Consignment Shops in Staten Island, NY

3 of the 8 antique stores we list in Staten Island have consignment. Whether a shop sells items on consignment (taking a cut when your piece sells) or only buys inventory outright is a business-model detail that never makes it into a map listing or category tag. Every shop on this page has consignment service confirmed from its own website or posted terms, not inferred from being generically 'antique.'

Love Your Furniture Again Antiques FurnitureJewelry & coinsConsignmentOpen Sunday

638 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10304-3806

🕒 Monday: 11am – 7pm

+14197991799 Website Directions

Old Beginnings Antiques & Consignment FurnitureJewelry & coinsConsignmentOpen Sunday

638 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10304-3806

🕒 Monday: 11am – 7pm

+13472477980 Website Directions

Richmond Consignments Consignment

1434 Richmond Rd Ste E, Staten Island, NY 10304-2324

17189804333 Website Directions

Get the consignment split and time limit in writing. Splits commonly fall somewhere between 50/50 and 60/40 in the seller's favor, and shops typically set a time window after which an unsold item is discounted, donated, or must be picked up — confirm both before you leave a piece.

More in Staten Island and New York

Good to know

How does antique consignment work?
You bring in an item, the shop displays and prices it for sale, and when it sells the store keeps an agreed percentage while you get the rest — you're paid only after the item actually sells, unlike selling outright to a dealer. Most shops set a consignment period, after which unsold items are marked down, returned, or donated per the agreement.

What percentage do consignment shops take?
It varies by shop and item type, but a 40-50% commission to the store is a common range for antiques and collectibles. Higher-value or harder-to-sell items sometimes carry different terms, so it's worth asking for the specific rate before consigning.