Antique Jewelry & Coin Shops in Madison, WI

6 of the 14 antique stores we list in Madison have jewelry & coins. A general antique-store listing tells you nothing about whether the shop actually deals in jewelry and coins versus furniture and glassware — that specialty usually only shows up buried in reviews or not at all. Every shop here has jewelry or coin dealing confirmed from its own site or posted signage, so you're not guessing from a generic category tag.

Antiques Mall of Madison Multi-dealer mallFurnitureJewelry & coinsOpen Sunday

4748 Cottage Grove Rd, Madison, WI 53716-1304

🕒 –Wed & Fri: 10am–6pm | Thurs: 10am–8pm

+16082222049 Website Directions

Atomic Antiques Multi-dealer mallFurnitureJewelry & coins

4546 Verona Rd, Madison, WI 53711-2735

+16086214500 Website Directions

Heirloom Cast Iron Cookware Multi-dealer mallFurnitureJewelry & coinsOpen Sunday

4546 Verona Rd, Madison, WI 53711-2735

Website Directions

Janet's Antiques FurnitureJewelry & coinsAppraisalsConsignmentOpen Sunday

3800 University Ave, Madison, WI 53705-2145

🕒 -Sat: 12pm-6pm

+16082383300 Website Directions

Maple Bluff Antique Mall Multi-dealer mallJewelry & coins

1922 S Stoughton Rd, Madison, WI 53716

(608) 243-3222 Website Directions

Treasure Trove Antiques And Collectibles- East Madison Jewelry & coins

4261 Lien Rd, Madison, WI 53704-3689

16082839210 Website Directions

Ask for a loupe and a scale before you buy. Reputable jewelry and coin dealers expect the question and will let you inspect hallmarks, purity stamps, or mint marks up close; a shop that resists a basic inspection is worth a second thought.

Also in Madison

Antique Jewelry & Coin Shops near Madison

Good to know

Do antique shops buy old coins?
Many antique and jewelry shops that deal in coins will buy or trade them, though pricing depends on the coin's rarity, condition, and metal content rather than age alone. Specialized coin dealers or coin shows typically offer more accurate appraisals than a general antique store.

How can I tell if antique jewelry is real gold or silver?
Look for a hallmark or purity stamp such as 14K, 18K, 925, or a maker's mark, though stamps can wear off or be missing on very old pieces. A jeweler can confirm metal content with an acid test or electronic tester, which is worth doing before paying a premium price.