All statesOhio › New Carlisle

Antique Stores in New Carlisle, OH

2 stores in and around New Carlisle, Ohio — call before you drive: many independent shops keep short or seasonal hours, and single-owner stores close without notice when the owner is out buying.

New Carlisle has about 5,511 residents, which works out to 36 antique stores per 100,000 people. Population: U.S. Census Bureau, 2024 estimate.

Comfort & Joy Eclectic Emporium Multi-dealer mall

106 S Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344

9373082945 Directions

Honeycreek Galleries

131 S Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344-1952

+19378453443 Directions

More stores within 30 miles of New Carlisle

Only 2 stores listed in New Carlisle itself, so here are the closest ones in nearby towns. Distance is straight-line from New Carlisle.

Under the Shady Tree Primitives and Antiques

📍 5.1 mi · 2964 Myers Rd, Springfield, OH 45502-8470

Directions

Ye Olde Meeting House Antiques

📍 5.8 mi · 7517 Old Troy Pike, Tipp City, OH 45371-8302

+19376577734 Directions

Patriot Antique Shoppe FurnitureJewelry & coinsOpen Sunday

📍 7.9 mi · 15 N 2nd St, Tipp City, OH 45371-1905

+19376671243 Website Directions

Benkin Antique Gallery

📍 7.9 mi · 14 E Main St, Tipp City, OH 45371

(937) 667-5526 Directions

Vintage In The Village Jewelry & coins

📍 7.9 mi · 6 S 3rd St, Tipp City, OH 45371

Website Directions

Midwest Memories Antiques Multi-dealer mallJewelry & coinsOpen Sunday

📍 8.0 mi · 24 W Main St, Tipp City, OH 45371-1809

🕒 Mon-Fri 10am-4pm, Sat 10am-5pm, Sun 12pm-4pm

+19376690316 Website Directions

Trash to Treasures

📍 9.3 mi · 7130 S County Road 25A, Tipp City, OH 45371-2522

+19376672637 Directions

Northwest Traders, Inc.

📍 9.3 mi · 5055 W Jackson Rd, Enon, OH 45323

+19373081591 Website Directions

Haggling: at multi-dealer malls the front desk can radio the booth owner for an offer — 10–15% off marked price is normal and expected on furniture and larger items. Smalls under $20 rarely move. Ask about a dealer discount if you resell, and always ask whether the price includes delivery on big pieces.

Ohio statewide, by feature

Nearby in Ohio

Good to know about antique stores in New Carlisle

How to polish silverware at home?
To polish silverware safely at home, apply a gentle commercial silver polish with a soft microfiber or cotton cloth using straight, back-and-forth motions. Alternatively, line a container with aluminum foil, add hot water, baking soda, and salt to remove tarnish through an electrochemical reaction. For detailed care tips and preservation advice, consult guides on AntiqueAtlas.

What baseball cards are worth money?
Baseball cards worth significant money generally feature Hall of Fame rookie players, low print runs, rare error variations, or vintage production dates prior to 1980. High physical condition grades from professional grading services like PSA or SGC also dramatically increase card value. You can use AntiqueAtlas to discover local sports memorabilia and antique card specialists.

Are Hummel figurines worth anything?
Hummel figurines can hold value, particularly older German porcelain pieces featuring rare trademark stamps or discontinued designs. Values range from modest sums for common mid-century models to hundreds of dollars for rare early editions in pristine condition. Search AntiqueAtlas to find local appraisal experts and vintage porcelain buyers.

Is uranium glass valuable?
Uranium glass—known for glowing bright green under ultraviolet light—is highly collectible, with values depending on color, maker, and rarity. Unique art glass pieces and intact dinnerware sets generally command higher prices among antique enthusiasts. Browse listings on AntiqueAtlas to connect with vintage glassware dealers.

More local guides for New Carlisle